Quick Facts...
- Diabetes management should consider nutrition, physical activity and
pharmacologic therapies.
- The overall goals of nutrition therapy include achievement and/or
maintenance of near-normal blood glucose and blood pressure levels,
optimal serum lipid levels and reasonable weight, the prevention of
acute and long-term complications, optimal nutrition and physical activity,
and consideration of personal and cultural preferences and lifestyle.
- There is no one diet prescription for people with diabetes. Four possible
alternative methods for planning diets use: 1) the Plate Model, 2) the
Diabetic Exchange Lists, 3) Carbohydrate Counting, and 4) the Food Guide
Pyramid.
Diabetes is the fifth-deadliest disease in the U.S. and has no cure.
Based on research of the last decade the American Diabetes Association
published an updated position statement in 2002 to replace recommendations
from 1994.
Diabetes encompasses a variety of metabolic abnormalities. The belief
that a single diabetic or ADA diet exists for people with diabetes is
no longer valid. Rather, it is recommended that people with diabetes work
with their diabetes management team (registered dietitian, nurse, physician
and other health care professionals, as needed) to develop a nutrition
care plan that fits their own metabolism, nutrition and lifestyle requirements.
Goals of Diabetes Management
The three cornerstones of diabetes management are diet, physical activity and
medication if needed (i.e., insulin or oral glucose-lowering agents).
Food raises blood glucose and blood fat levels. Activity and medications
lower blood glucose and blood fat levels.
Type 1 Diabetes
Diabetes is categorized as type 1 or type 2, based on the underlying
physiological problem. Type 1 diabetes, formerly known as insulin-dependent
diabetes mellitus (IDDM), is characterized by the destruction of the pancreatic
beta cells that produce insulin. The end result is absolute insulin deficiency.
Insulin must be taken regularly. Type 1 diabetes occurs most often in
children and young adults, but it can occur at any age.
Previously, people who took insulin had to follow a rigid pattern of
eating. This sometimes created conflicts that resulted in varying degrees
of noncompliance. The current recommendations are more flexible; they
recommend integrating insulin therapy into the individual’s usual
eating and exercise patterns. They also allow a person to adjust the timing
and quantity of insulin injected in accordance with monitored blood glucose
levels.
A primary treatment goal in type 1 diabetes should be tight blood glucose
control. Frequent blood glucose monitoring is recommended. Blood glucose
monitoring can show which foods, physical activities and/or times of the
day elevate an individual’s blood glucose level. By adjusting insulin
dose to meet needs, a person may have more near-normal blood glucose levels
and help reduce the risk for short- and long-term complications.
It is still highly recommended that people using insulin therapy eat
at consistent times and consume consistent amounts of carbohydrates to
synchronize with the time-action of the insulin preparation they are using.
However, by using multiple daily injections and frequent monitoring of
blood glucose levels, people with diabetes can quickly adjust to account
for changes from their usual eating and exercise habits.
Type 2 Diabetes
Type 2 diabetes, formerly known as non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus
(NIDDM), is by far the most common form of the condition. More than 90
percent of all people with diabetes have this type.
Type 2 diabetes develops because of insulin resistance, in which the
body is unable to use insulin properly, combined with a relative (not
absolute) insulin deficiency. The risk of developing type 2 diabetes increases
with age, obesity and lack of physical activity. Typically, adults with
type 2 diabetes are over 45, overweight and sedentary, with a family history
of diabetes, and have high blood pressure and high cholesterol. There’s
a greater possibility that women in this group had diabetes during pregnancy
and delivered a baby that weighed more than 9 pounds. Recently, however,
we have seen an alarming trend in the United States of type 2 diabetes
developing in adolescence. These youth tend to be older than 10 years
of age, experiencing puberty, and have a strong family history of type
2 diabetes. Diabetes is also more common in African Americans, Latinos,
Native Americans, Asian-Americans and Pacific Islanders.
Total calories consumed should be sufficient to maintain a desirable
weight and prevent weight gain. Achieving and maintaining weight loss
has long been a primary dietary focus for people with type 2 diabetes.
Physical activity on a regular basis is recommended. Aiming for blood
glucose control, along with normal blood lipid levels and normal blood
pressure are also important goals. These factors, if controlled, help
reduce the risk of long-term complications of diabetes.
An initial strategy for type 2 diabetes is to improve food choices to
better meet the recommendations of the Dietary Guidelines for Americans
and the Food Guide Pyramid. Reducing fat, especially saturated fat, is
highly recommended. Plan to eat meals throughout the day to spread nutrient
intake. Even mild to moderate weight loss (10 to 20 pounds) has been shown
to improve diabetes control. Lifestyle changes that moderately decrease
calorie intake (250 to 500 kcal/day) and increase energy expenditure are
strongly encouraged.
Major Nutrient Recommendations
Protein. Protein intake accounts for 15 to 20 percent of total
daily calories consumed among the general population as well as those
with diabetes. There is no evidence to indicate the usual protein intake
should be modified if renal function is normal. A protein intake above
20 percent may have a detrimental effect on development of nephropathy
(renal disease).
Fat and Carbohydrate. The most life-threatening consequences
of diabetes are cardiovascular disease (CVD) and stroke, which strike
people with diabetes more than twice as often as others. Diabetes itself
is a strong independent risk factor for CVD. Thus, steps that help reduce
this risk are important.
In persons with diabetes there are two primary goals for fat consumption:
limit saturated fat and dietary cholesterol. Saturated fat is linked to
low density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol levels. It is recommended that
less than 10 percent of calories should come from saturated fat. Individuals
with LDL cholesterol greater than or equal to 100 mg/dl may benefit from
lowering their intake of saturated fat intake to less than 7 percent of
calories consumed. To lower LDL cholesterol, calories from saturated fat
can be reduced for weight loss or replaced by carbohydrate or protein
if no weight loss is desired.
Total fat should be 30 to 35 percent or total calories. Polyunsaturated
fat is limited to 10 percent and monounsaturated fat to 20 percent of
total calories.
Dietary cholesterol should be less than 300 mg/day. Those individuals
with LDL cholesterol greater than or equal to 100 mg/dl may benefit from
lowering dietary cholesterol to less than 200 mg/day. Elevated levels
of triglycerides (greater than 150 mg/dl) are also a risk factor for CVD.
The addition of exercise may result in greater decreases in total and
LDL cholesterol and triglycerides, and prevent a decrease in high density
lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol. Plant stanols or plant sterols, such as
those found in cholesterol-lowering margarines, should be in the amount
of approximately 2 g/day.
Intake of trans fatty acids should be limited. The effect of trans fatty
acids is similar to saturated fat in raising LDL cholesterol. In addition,
trans fatty acids lower HDL cholesterol which is not desirable.
Current fat replacers, approved by the FDA, may help reduce dietary fat
intake, including saturated fat and cholesterol, but they may not reduce
calories or result in weight loss. Reduced-fat diets can contribute to
weight loss and improvement of abnormal blood lipids over the long term.
Guidelines for cholesterol management, recommended in May 2001, replaced
the National Cholesterol Education Program's (NCEP's) Step II diet. These
new guidelines, issued in the Adult Treatment Panel III (ATP III), recommend
Therapeutic Lifestyle Changes (TLC), a lifestyle approach to reduce CVD.
For people with diabetes whose LDL cholesterol is above the goal level
for their category of risk fsor heart disease, TLC is recommended. The
TLC approach includes a cholesterol-lowering diet, physical activity and
weight management.
Sugar. It was previously believed that simple sugars
are more rapidly digested and absorbed than starches, and therefore are
more likely to cause high blood sugar levels. This premise has not been
supported by scientific evidence. The 2002 guidelines allow the use of
sugar and sugar-containing foods in modest amounts as part of a
balanced diet. It should be remembered, however, that sugar-containing
foods must be substituted for other carbohydrate foods and not simply
added on top of what is eaten. The first consideration should be the total
amount of carbohydrate eaten. This does not mean that sweets should be
eaten with every meal or even every day. Sweets also can be high in calories.
As stated in fact sheet 9.353, Dietary Guidelines for Americans,
moderation is the key.
Non-nutritive Sweeteners. Saccharin, aspartame, acesulfame
potassium (K) and sucralose have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration
(FDA) and can be used by people with diabetes, including pregnant women,
within a balanced diet. Because saccharin can cross the placenta, other
sweeteners are better choices during pregnancy. (See fact sheet 9.301,
Sugar and Sweeteners.)
Fiber. Fiber recommendations for people with diabetes
are the same as for the general population, 20 to 35 grams from a wide
variety of sources daily. Of the recommended total fiber intake, 10 to
25 g/day should come from soluble fiber. Because of the potential beneficial
effect of soluble fibers on serum lipids and glucose metabolism, people
with diabetes are advised to get adequate amounts of fiber from the carbohydrates
they eat. Good sources of soluble fiber include oat products, many fruits
and vegetables, cooked beans, rice bran and psyllium seeds. (See fact
sheet 9.333, Dietary Fiber.)
Methods for Planning Diets
Dietary management of diabetes should be designed to meet total nutrient
and health needs, not just blood glucose needs. Begin with an assessment
of the individual’s usual eating habits, including food likes and
dislikes, eating and work schedules, as well as treatment goals identified
by the health care team. The better dietary management fits into one’s
usual routine, the more likely it is to be successful. The following diet
planning systems can be helpful when planning meals and snacks for people
with diabetes.
 |
| The Plate Method. |
Plate Method. The Plate Method is a simple method for
teaching meal planning. A 9-inch dinner plate serves as a pie chart to
show proportions of the plate that should be covered by various food groups.
This meal planning approach is simple and versatile. Vegetables should
cover 50 percent of the plate for lunch and dinner. The remainder of the
plate should be divided between starchy foods, such as bread, grains,
or potatoes, and a choice from the meat group. A serving of fruit and
milk are represented outside the plate.
Diabetic Exchange Diets. In this system, food is separated
into six categories based on macro nutrient content (i.e., starch [cereals,
grains, pasta, bread, beans, and starchy vegetables], meat and meat-substitutes,
non-starchy vegetables, fruits, milk and fats). Individuals, with the
help of a physician or dietitian, design a daily meal plan based on a
set amount of servings from each category. The Food Exchange method allows
a person to measure rather than weigh food. This saves time and encourages
compliance. Any food may be substituted for another within the same food
exchange list. As with other methods, all meals and snacks should be eaten
at about the same time each day and be consistent in the amount of food
consumed.
Carbohydrate Counting. Some people choose to count the
grams of carbohydrate in various foods, and adjust the amount of carbohydrate
consumed during the day as a reflection of blood glucose levels. One choice
from the starch, fruits, milk, or sweets and dessert list supplies about
15 grams of carbohydrate. Each selection is considered one carbohydrate
choice. A meal plan outlines the number of carbohydrate choices a person
may select for meals and snacks. This method requires great diligence
with diet and blood glucose monitoring.
Dietary Guidelines/MyPyramid. MyPyramid strives to put
the Dietary Guidelines for Americans into action. It provides a
conceptual framework for selecting the kinds and amounts of various foods,
which together provide a nutritious diet. MyPyramid focuses on variety
and on reducing the amount of added fat and sugar in the diet. The bread/cereal,
vegetable and fruit groups make up the base of the diet. For more details,
see fact sheet 9.306, A Guide to Daily Food Choices.
Using Nutritional Labeling
With any of the diet planning methods mentioned above, the nutrition
facts label found on most foods can provide much useful information. If
you are counting carbohydrates, total grams of carbohydrates per serving
are listed on the label, along with grams of sugars and dietary fiber.
For more information on food labeling, request 9.365, Understanding
the Food Label.
If you are using the exchange lists method of diet planning, exchanges
can be developed for new foods based on the grams of protein, carbohydrate
and fat provided per serving. Be aware that the serving sizes given on
labels may not be the same as those used in the Exchange Lists for Meal
Planning. For example, the label serving size for orange juice is 8 fluid
ounces. In the Exchange Lists, the serving size in 4 ounces (1/2 cup).
Thus, a person who drinks 1 cup of orange juice has consumed two fruit
exchanges.
If you are using the MyPyramid in menu planning, pay close attention
to the percent daily value column of the nutrition facts label. Look for
foods that have low percent daily values for fat, saturated fat and cholesterol,
and high percent daily values for fiber. Also note the calories per serving,
calories from fat, and the trans fat content. (All food labels now list
trans fat content.)
For more information:
American Diabetes Association: www.diabetes.org or 1-800-342-2383
American Dietetic Association: www.eatright.com/catalog or 1-800-877-1600
ext. 5000
National Diabetes Education Program: ndep.nih.gov
or 1-800-438-538
References
- Diabetes Threat on the Rise Among U.S. Children, Specialists Say.
Chronic disease notes and reports. National Center for Chronic
Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Vol. 12 No. 2, Spring/Summer
1999.
- Executive Summary of the Third Report of the National Cholesterol
Education Program (NCEP) Expert Panel on Detection, Evaluation, and
Treatment of High Blood Cholesterol in Adults (Adult Treatment Panel
III). JAMA. 2001, 285(19):2486-2497.
- Franz, M.J., Bantle, J.P., Beebe, C.A., Brunzell, J.D., Chiasson,
J.L., Garg, A., Holzmeister, L.A., Hoogwerf, B., Mayer-Davis, E.,
Mooradian, A.D., Purnell, J.Q. and Wheeler, M. Evidence-Based Nutrition
Principles and Recommendations for the Treatment and Prevention of
Diabetes and Related Complications. Diabetes Care. 2002; 25(1):148-198.
- Funnell, M.M., Hunt, C., Kulkarni, K., Rubin, R.R., and Yarborough,
P.C.. A Core Curriculum for Diabetes Education. 3rd ed. American
Association of Diabetes Educators, Chicago, Ill. 1998.
- Kurtzweil, P. The New Food Label: Coping with Diabetes. FDA Consumer
1994; November:20-25.
- Position Statement of the American Diabetes Association. Evidence-Based
Nutrition Principles and Recommendations for the Treatment and Prevention
of Diabetes and Related Complications. Diabetes Care. 2003; Volume
26, Supplement 1.
- Position Statement of the American Diabetes Association. Evidence-Based
Nutrition Principles and Recommendations for the Treatment and Prevention
of Diabetes and Related Complications. Diabetes Care. 2003; Volume
26, Supplement 1.
|
