CSU Extension Home Agriculture at Colorado State University Cooperative Extensioin
Putting Knowledge to Work Colorado State University Extension
4-H/YouthAgricultureFamily ConsumerHorticultureNatural ResourcesNutrition ResourcesCounty OfficesHome

Margarine vs. Butter:
The Trans Fat Debate


By Pat Kendall, Ph.D., R.D.
Food Science and Human Nutrition Specialist
Colorado State University Extension
April 22, 1998
 

Just when you thought you knew which types of fats to watch out for on nutrition labels, you begin hearing about "trans fats", and they're not even mentioned on the label!

Trans fats are formed during a process in which vegetable oils are heated and exposed to hydrogen gas. This process, called hydrogenation, changes the structure of the fat in some places along its carbon backbone. The added hydrogen exerts a slight pull that rotates the fat chain, changing the configuration from what in chemistry is called "cis" to "trans." Thus the name trans fats. The process is done to improve the texture and keeping quality of oil-based fats.

Trans fats also occur naturally, mainly in meat and dairy products. Overall, trans fats make up from 2 to 4 percent of the calories in our diet, compared to 12 percent for saturated fats and 30 percent for total fats.

Hydrogenated fats are nothing new. In 1911, cottonseed oil was first hydrogenated in the United States to produce vegetable shortening as a replacement for lard. The manufacturing process became more established in the 1930s as margarine entered the scene. As diets high in saturated fat became more strongly associated with high blood cholesterol and elevated risk of heart disease, more people began switching to lower saturated-fat products like vegetable margarine.

And, research has shown this was a good change. In the past 30 years since low saturated fat diets have been advocated, there has been steady progress in reducing the overall risk of developing heart disease among Americans. However, a spate of new research has brought trans fats into the limelight, conjuring confusion about the best recommendations for fat intake and heart disease once again.

Specifically Consumers are asking, "What's better for your heart, butter or margarine?" While most researchers still agree margarine is better, they recommend tub margarines over stick varieties to reduce the level of trans fats, and recommend spreading both butter and margarine lightly to lower overall calories from fat.

The evidence that saturated fat, like that found in butter, raises total and LDL cholesterol, or bad cholesterol, is still intact. What the new evidence on trans fats says is that Consumers at risk of heart disease need to be careful not to replace the saturated fat in their diets with foods high in hydrogenated oils, a mistake that's all too easy to make. Processed foods marketed low cholesterol and low in saturated fat are often the very foods high in trans unsaturated fats.

While there's no category for trans fats on the nutrition panel, foods high in trans fats are those that list partially hydrogenated vegetable oil on the ingredient list.

Common sources of trans fats include stick margarines, savory and fried snack foods such as crackers, potato chips and corn chips, and baked goods and pastries including packaged cookies, doughnuts and desserts.

The skinny on fats? Most experts emphasize reducing fat in general and replacing saturated fats in the diet with fats shown to have a beneficial effect on cholesterol levels. These are the non-hydrogenated polyunsaturated and monounsaturated vegetable oils. Polyunsaturated fats include safflower, corn and soybean oils; monounsaturated fats include olive and canola oils.

For more information, contact your local Colorado State University Extension office.


Go to top of this page.
Updated Tuesday, November 27, 2007.

AnswerLink | Employment | Other Links | Publications | Staff Resources | Site Search
CSU Home | RamPoint | About Us | Calendar | Staff Directory | Webmaster
Disclaimer | Equal Opportunity | Non-Discrimination Statement