CSU Extension Home Agriculture at Colorado State University Cooperative Extensioin
Putting Knowledge to Work Colorado State University Extension
4-H/YouthAgricultureFamily ConsumerHorticultureNatural ResourcesNutrition ResourcesCounty OfficesHome

Car financing - beware of hidden charges

By Kay Zimka
Colorado State University
Extension agent, Family and Consumer Sciences
 

Consumers who are buying a new car often compare sticker price, appearance, drivability, features-even extras, service, warranty and a whole package of additional considerations. Another cost that a consumer should compare is the auto finance charge.

A study released in January 2004, conducted by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), found that car buyers who finance their cars at automobile dealerships might be paying enormous undisclosed "finance mark-up charges." The mark-up occurs when automobile dealers subjectively hike the car loan rates of buyers who finance their purchase through those dealers. According to CFA, "Consumers are led to believe they are receiving a rate based on their creditworthiness, but often pay marked up finance rates determined arbitrarily by the dealer and encouraged by the lender." Most of these undisclosed mark-up charges are kicked back to the dealer by the lender. Such mark-ups typically add at least $1,000 to the cost of an auto loan and historically have affected about 25 percent of consumers who arrange car loans through the dealers. The report indicates that African-American and Hispanic car buyers are marked up more often than other buyers. The report argues that the solution must include: disclosure of the mark-up percentage and dollar costs, flat fees that are a one-time charge paid to dealers for placing a loan that do not fluctuate and are not based on the loan amount OR the term of the loan, remedy programs for those already harmed by the hidden charges, and consumer education programs designed to give consumers a clear understanding of the automotive finance process and to promote consumer awareness of remedy programs. For a copy of the full report is click here to access the Consumer Federation of America Web Site

In addition to including how new cars compare and reliability ratings for new cars in its April issues, Consumer Reports suggests that consumers arrange financing in advance. Look at interest rates at several credit unions, banks or loan providers before checking dealer's rates. Consumers who are preapproved for an auto loan can keep financial arrangements out of the negotiations.

Be aware that the dealership salesperson may try to sign you up for a higher rate than you could get in another place. Negotiate one thing at a time. Dealers may give the consumer a better price in one area while inflating figures in another. Only after you've settled on the purchase price of the vehicle should you discuss financing or trade-in. Negotiate each item individually. If the dealer offers zero percent financing, they will not give consumers a rebate on the sale price. Car buyers should think about whether they should take the rebate and finance the purchase through their bank or credit union. They can work with their financial institution to compare their calculations with those of the dealer.

Remember, consumers should be talking to their bank or credit union, not the representative from the dealership. Keep in mind, you can leave the dealership at any time. Let the dealer know that you will visit other dealerships selling the same car and will buy from the dealer offering the best price. In addition to checking on information at dealerships you can check the quotes for purchase price at auto-buying Web sites such as: Edmunds Web Site ; The Kelly Blue Book Web Site; Autobytel Web Site; Autotrader Web Site; and Autos MSN Web Site.

Before you buy that car, be sure you know the answers to these questions: What is the:

  • exact (down to the penny) price of the auto?
  • total amount being financed?
  • amount for the credit/finance charge?
  • annual percentage rate (APR)?
  • exact amount of each payment?
  • total number of payments?

The best advice - be prepared when buying and financing that vehicle.

Colorado State University Extension provides unbiased, research-based information about family and consumer issues, gardening, natural resources, agriculture and 4-H youth development. As part of a nation-wide system, Extension brings the research and resources of the University to the community. For more information click here to visit the Colorado State University Web Site or theAnswer Link Web Site, where answers to everyday questions are available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.


Go to top of this page.
Updated Friday, October 12, 2007.

AnswerLink | Employment | Other Links | Publications | Staff Resources | Site Search
CSU Home | RamPoint | About Us | Calendar | Staff Directory | Webmaster
Disclaimer | Equal Opportunity | Non-Discrimination Statement